Subject: [ieee-ietf-coord] my notes from the IETF – IEEE 802 breakfast meeting at IETF 96

From: "Romascanu, Dan (Dan)" <[email-masked]>
Date: Wed, 27 Jul 2016 16:29:03 +0000

Hi,

Thanks all for the participation in the IETF – IEEE 802 breakfast meeting at IETF 96. Here are my summary notes. Please let me know if I missed anything important.

1.                   Preparation for the f2f meeting on 9/9 – logistics and agenda

- Registration for the meeting needs to be done on the wiki page, than call the hotel and send them the filled-in form distributed by Cindy

- At least one participant got problems with travel approval to Paris because of travel advisory and company process. If there are other in the same situation, please let Pat, Dan and Cindy know

- Agenda seems right. The approaches to 5G standardization will be owned by Glenn and Suresh

2.                   YANG models for VLANs work in the IETF and IEEE – Robert Wilton

- Robert updated shortly on the status; consensus that we need to avoid a standard solution that configures VLANs in ways that break IEEE 802.1 compliant networks; Experimental or Informational RFCs may not solve the problem

- John clarified that in order to have the issue addressed at the IEEE Plenary next week, it would be very useful for the IETF to send a liaison statement to IEEE 802.1. (Benoit sent it on Friday 7/22)

3.                   Opportunistic Wireless Encryption – Dan Harkins

        - presentation of the issue by Dan H; the balance is between a timely solution and respecting the areas of expertise of each SDO and its processes; complete solution (TG in .11) is also the slowest (~ 2 yrs. to complete)

        - form a mail group to discuss solutions – include Dan Harkins, Warren Kumari, Pat Thaler, Adrian Stephens, Dorothy Stanley, Stephen Farrell, John Messenger, Don Eastlake, Walter Penciak, Dan Romascanu

4.                   Copyright for IEEE documents in IETF documents - Suresh Krishnan

-          Added at the meeting; Suresh presented the issue – is it allowed to include text from IEEE standards in IETF I-Ds, if yes, what is the right process?

-          Organize a conference call to discuss this issue, involve Legal on both sides. Participants: Suresh, Pat, Jodi Hasz, Jose Contreras, Yvette HoSang, Anasthasie Sainvilus, Karen O’Donogue

Regards,

Dan