Subject: Re: L3VPN @IETF73 Draft Minutes

From: Danny McPherson <[email-masked]>
Date: Mon, 15 Dec 2008 18:50:59 -0700

Folks,
I received ZERO comments on this initial draft version
of the minutes, inclusive of ZERO clarifying comments on
Who or what the following '?'s represent.

So, if were, or know who the comments below were from,
please let me know.

Also, Dave McDysan, if you could replace the '???' with
the proper text I'd appreciate it.

Thanks all!

-danny

-
 > ? from Cisco: we pretty much agree that there is only one single  
item to be worked on in the considerations draft. Don't understand why  
we have to block to consider the partitioning draft.
-
 > ? : mentions that IPv4 or IPv6 prefixes can be carried in OSPFv3,  
new extended community could be attached to both of them. What happens  
to old extended community?
-
 > ? (same as before): do we want to clarify what happens if multiple  
type 3 LSAs are aggregated. Need to say ... (DN bit set).
-
 > ? : Inter-area routes propagated by BGP. On other end will generate  
type 3 LSA. Address range might be configured there, and type 3 LSA  
might fall into it. Need to specify that the DN bit needs to be set.
-
 > ? : up to the user; should we clarify the protocol behavior
-
 > Dave McDyson (sp?): think more work needs to be done to take the  
requirements to split out C-TE over ???.  Document needs editing to  
make it clearer. My comments are 26 pages long (doc is 22 pages long).  
Want my comments addressed before last call. PCE has to handle the  
fact that you may have duplicate IP addresses coming from customers;  
may need to extend protocol.
-

On Nov 23, 2008, at 2:14 PM, Danny McPherson wrote:

>
> Folks,
> The draft minutes from the session last Thursday
> are available in the IETF 73 Meeting Materials
> repository here:
>
> <http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/08nov/minutes/l3vpn.txt>
>
> Please review the minutes and provide me (and/or the WG)
> with any corrections ASAP.  In particular, if you made
> comments at the microphone or presented please review the
> file for question marks that may be associated either with
> your name or comments provided.
>
> Many thanks to Steven Blake for serving as scribe and
> doing an excellent job capturing discussions during the
> session.
>
> Last Call for input on the minutes will be December 9,
> 2008.
>
> Thanks!
>
> Danny & Marshall