Subject: [manet] Checklist of basic AODVv2 issues to close

From: Charlie Perkins <[email-masked]>
Date: Tue, 24 Mar 2015 07:55:06 -0700

Hello folks,

Here is the first of two lists of issues for AODVv2.  The issues
  in this list were able to be resolved by fairly simple changes
to the document over the last several revisions.  Please take
a look to make sure that the issue resolution is satisfactory.
If the resolutions are satisfactory, then the issues should all
be closed.  Otherwise, comments for further resolution will
be appreciated.

19    Use of square brackets
         ... every instance checked
20    Idle routes must be marked as active after re-use
         ... done
22    Multiple terms for same concept
         ... fixed
25    Meaning of "suppose"
         ... term no longer appears
27    Processing AckReq
         ... Description clarified
29    Choice of IP address
         ... Text clarified; natural IP address as used by application
30    Use of word "node"
         ... Expanded use of IP address instead
31    Suitability for implementation on commodity OS
         ... Text added as discussed -  see issue 46 also - features of 
IP needed by AODVv2 - Appendix G
39    Route.Broken flag redundant
         ... Fixed
40    AckReq vs RREP_ACK
         ... Clarified that RREP_Ack is the response to AckReq
41    AckReq vs RREP_ACK
         ... Duplication
42    What happens if Active routes exceed RERR packet size?
         ... Specified need for multiple RERR messages
49    Locating pseudocode in appendix (submitted for Chris Dearlove)
         ... pseudocode no longer deals with RFC 5444 fields
56    Issue concerning RREQ redundancy check methodology and order
         ... Revisions made for best efficiency
57    Need to further restrict "LoopFree" condition
         ... Done
58    Definitions of OrigNode and TargNode (Submitted for Justin Dean)
         ... Added
59    Use of the term "invalid" (Submitted for Justin Dean)
         ... Resolution related to issue #61
60    Should OrigNode be included in the message header? (... Justin Dean)
         ... fixed
61    Difference between "broken" and "expired" (Submitted for Justin Dean)
         ... States coalesced, renamed to be "invalid"
62    Inconsistency surrounding the "timed" state (Submitted for Justin 
Dean)
         ... fixed
63    {Orig,Targ}.Tail should be {Orig,Targ}.Mid
         ... fixed

Regards,
Vicky and Charlie P.