Subject: [martini] Very rough notes for Friday MARTINI meeting @ IETF#77

From: David Hancock <[email-masked]>
Date: Fri, 26 Mar 2010 15:51:22 -0600

Adam Roach's presentation of new version of GIN draft:
-          Provided summary of updates
-          No comments received

Dean Willis' presentation on security considerations on Path and Service-Route
-          There may be an issue between Service Route and Outbound

Keith Drage: Service Route works for IMS implicit registration, which is different than the registration procedure proposed by GIN.

Hadriel Kaplan: Although IMS and GIN registration procedures differ, they are the same w.r.t. Service Route; i.e., they are both registering multiple AORs with a single REGISER transaction.

John Elwell's presentation on MARTINI requirements draft:

Christer Holmberg: Has a problem with REQ16 - the RU requirement.

Dale Worley: Clarified this requirement - which is that the solution should not constrain the PBX from assigning GRUUs to its UAs in the usual way.

Paul Kyzivat: This requirement is also about addressing the fact that the SIP-PBX doesn't itself have a globally unique address, and therefore must get some help from the SSP network to provide a globally unique address.

Dale Worley must allow the SIP-PBX it's UAs GRUUs as defined in the GRUU RFC.

John Elwell: Please post clarifying updates to the list.

End of notes - had to leave early...

David