Subject: [ppsp] Is P2PSIP RELOAD not suitable to be leverage for both P2P Live Streaming and VoD Service?

From: World <[email-masked]>
Date: Mon, 15 Mar 2010 21:14:11 +0800 (CST)

Dear all,
 
I am thinking what P2P Live Streaming and VoD Service can leverage P2PSIP RELOAD. According to some research or proposal report, it seems that P2PSIP RELOAD can be used in P2P-based Tracker and/or chunk description distribution (chunk discovery) at the full distributed deployment. Both P2P-based Tracker and chunk description distribution over P2PSIP overlay were evaluated in performance referred to draft-chen-ppsp-dht-chunk-discovery-evaluation-00.txt and draft-hu-ppsp-tracker-dht-performance-comparison-01.txt. The result showed the performance of DHT-based Tracker and chunk description distribution is worse, even not acceptable for P2P Live Streaming and VoD Service.
 
So can we make such conclusion that P2PSIP RELOAD is not suitable to be leverage for both P2P Live Streaming and VoD Service in case a full distributed deployment is not mandatory? What do you think?
 
Any comments are welcome. Thanks.
 
BR,
Jeffrey