Subject: [Softwires] WG consensus declaration

From: "Durand, Alain" <[email-masked]>
Date: Thu, 23 Mar 2006 17:05:05 -0500

(This is sent as a preview of the meeting minutes that will be available
shortly)
 
At that Softwires interim meeting in Hong Kong in February, 
attendees reached consensus on solutions for both scenarios:
*    L2TPv2 was selected as Phase 1 solution for H&S 
*    L2TPv3 was selected as Phase 2 solution for H&S 
*    Combined MPBGP solutions from Yong Cui and C. Metz
                       was selected for Mesh solution
 
The chairs posted on March 3rd a message to the Softwires mailing list
with the title:
"Notes and Consensus from Interim Meeting in Hong Kong".
A number of clarification questions were asked on the mailing list
since,
involving much interesting discussion involving many wg participants on
TTM,
support, deployment and technical criteria.
No open issues are considered remaining to this day.
 
At the IETF65 Softwires meeting, a formal evaluation of technical
criteria
and a vision of the consensus reached in Honk Kong and on the mailing
list
was presented. A show of hands during the meeting has the following
result:
 
Do you believe the wg has reached rough consensus for the choice L2TPv2
as phase 1 for H&S:
    - Yes: 33+ hands
    - No: 3 hands
 
Given all the above, the wg chairs are formally declaring wg rough
consensus on the choices
expressed in Hong Kong.
 
On to Phase 2!"
 
     - Alain & David, Softwires co-chairs.

*
_______________________________________________
Softwires mailing list
[email-masked]
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/softwires